New Marketing Trends

Marketing Ideas for Non-Profits and Libraries

The M Word helps librarians learn about marketing trends and ideas.

Tuesday, February 19, 2013

The War for Libraries Continues...

Ahhh, the good old days... When libraries were the only places that held information, nobody questioned their existence. Now that we live in a world of information overload, too many people are questioning their value, and even speaking out against libraries directly because they [gasp!] cost money.

The latest big battle began on 12 February in a local UK newspaper, Sunderland Echo, with an article called "Sunderland libraries facing closure under £850,000 savings plan." The article quoted one author who was against the budget-driven closure, then it quoted another author, Terry Deary, who favors the closure:
Sunderland-born Terry Deary welcomed the plans and told the Echo the future of reading lies with e-books.He said: “Libraries have had their day. They are a Victorian idea and we are in an electronic age. They either have to change and adapt or they have to go.“I know some people like them but fewer and fewer people are using them and these are straightened times. A lot of the gush about libraries is sentimentality.
As you can imagine, discussion ensued. More papers picked up on the controversy. The Guardian, a major UK newspaper, ran an article with this heading on 13 February: 
Author of children's bestsellers Terry Deary says they are a drain on taxpayers and authors that no longer makes sense"

Deary's main argument is that, when libraries buy books and lend them many times, they are taking money away from publishers and authors because they are cutting down on the individual sales of books. Here is the basis of his argument: 
... we've got this idea that we've got an entitlement to read books for free, at the expense of authors, publishers and council tax payers. This is not the Victorian age, when we wanted to allow the impoverished access to literature. We pay for compulsory schooling to do that," said Deary...
A firestorm followed. The Guardian article is not yet a week old, yet it has been shared on Facebook 3,115 time and Tweeted 815 times (and certainly there are more shares not measured directly from the site). The article itself has 359 comments. And of course, other media have picked up on it.

The best response I've read was in The Huffington Post on 15 Feb. The essay "Why Terry Deary Is Wrong: The Case for Libraries" was written by author and blogger Foz Meadows. She makes many points that specifically answer Deary's comments, especially on his belief that libraries take money from authors.

I share all of this here to point out, once again, that we need to constantly speak up for libraries and to explain their value to everyone who has a stake in them. While it's good that there are comments in our favor when articles like this appear, in a way, that's almost too late. If everyone understood why libraries still matter in the digital age, then fewer articles like this would be written in the first place. 

This is but one more battle in the continuing war for libraries. We all need to be "armed" with facts, elevator speeches, and passionate soundbites. If you don't feel that you are good at coming up with your own quotes or arguments, there are a lot that you can use. 
Please don't ever be afraid to speak up on behalf of libraries every time you have an opportunity to discuss them. If we want these institutions to continue to exist, it's vital.


Anonymous said...

Excellent article, many thanks.

~Kathy Dempsey said...

Oh, I almost forgot that I wanted to include this link:

A recent study by Library Journal found evidence that library sales drive consumer book purchases. (tho the study covered the US and Deary is in the UK)

Read about this and more: " It reports that over 50 percent of all library users go on to buy books by an author they were first introduced to at the library. This figure holds true for infrequent library users as well as for those who go to the library often to borrow materials. Both buy nearly the same number of books each year, too."